Mortal Justice

I was really intrigued by my small group's question in class on Tuesday. We had been given the question "Would you still believe in God were there no heaven or hell?" I thought about the ramifications of what this meant in terms of God's absolute justness. How just can God be if there is no eternal atonement for mankind's sin? There is some level of justice in the world, though. Man is not immortal but suffers through sickness and pain. Governments impose temporary justice for immoral crime and wickedness. The moral of the story for anyone at that point would just be to avoid breaking any laws. If everyone dies but there's no legitimate specific consequences for sin outside of law (i.e., one doesn't contract cancer because they envied someone or were too prideful), there's no reason to do anything other than live to better yourself. Sure, charity and good works out of the kindness of your own heart are nice, but they're not as fulfilling as making money or being the most important person in your workplace. I wonder what all this would mean for morality/conscience. I feel like this would be a very jaded and cynical world, but to be completely honest, it might not be that different from the real world.

Comments

I agree, if there were no heaven or hell then what would be the purpose of good in the world. As humans, most the time we work harder when given a reason to. If we were to have no incentive or purpose to do good in the world, then we would be in more trouble than we already are. I also agree with you though because our world is very cynical, but personally believe it could be much worse!
Madison Flowers said…
I have had someone ask me this question before, about if I would still believe in God if there were no heaven or hell? I think you answered this very well and very honestly. There would be very little incentive for people to strive for good. It would be a scary world to see. I think Mackenzie is right, it could be much worse.