What the Thunder Said - Rebecca Belew

I thought Dr. Schuler was being facetious when he told us that we would have to read over The Wasteland a second or even a third time, but he wasn't joking around, this took some close reading to grasp even a simple part of the poem. As I was reading I tried to figure out how this tied into Silence and where the parallels would fall... then I came to it... the best part of it all, and the parallel of the century.

What the Thunder Said

The fifth and final Canto of Eliot's epic poem.

The notes in my book started off by immediately telling the reader that this part of Eliot's work rendered a unique depiction of the betrayal, arrest, interrogation, and crucifixion of Christ. This section started off with the narrator repeatedly saying, "If there were water," symbolizing the thirst for Christ and His infinite goodness, the same thirst Rodrigues feels both physically and spiritually in Silence.

Along with that, the narrator of this section talks about how the mountains themselves are not silent, the rocks are crying out, the earthquake is nigh, and the thunder has come with no rain in sight. If only there were water. There is not even silence in the mountains.
The LORD tells us in His Word that should we not praise Him then the rocks would cry out, and although this is not the ideal moment for praise, maybe the rocks were meant to cry out in His pain as well.

The section then continues on, seeming to recount on times that Christ was ignored while walking beside humans, nations falling, sexual sin being committed, the things that He died for. Yet, it does not discount the compassion of the Lord and His control over all situations.

"The sea was calm, your heart would have responded/Gaily, when invited, beating obedient/To controlling hands"

Christ gave himself as a martyr for humanity, and when it all seemed bleak and hopeless, still He was in control.

"The sea was calm" even when it looked wild.

Comments: Jacob & Caroline

Comments

Jamie Peters said…
I completely forgot about trying to relate "Silence" to this! It is incredibly interesting to see how much Eliot relates everything back to Christ, especially his death. There is a certain war parallel that can also be made with this, that Christ laid down his life much like the soldiers in WW1 did for their country.
Drew Hedden said…
I wasn't in class on Thursday so all of this was completely new to me. Fascinating! I appreciate your insight and you do a great job of drawing the parallels.
Osten said…
That is an interesting viewpoint however I saw it differently. When I read it I saw the rocks and sand to be the landscape, farmland, and cities and so forth, and the water represents life and maybe literal water. The cities, farmland, and people are so barren and lifeless even one drop of "water" would make life bearable. This theory is also backed by the connection to the metaphor in the first chapter where Elliot compares life to hell.
Rachael Gregson said…
While I saw the reason of this poem to portray the society's intellectual decline, I really love how you thought of it in the spiritual sense. In fact, yours fits it much better. We do live in a time where we're forever thirsty and our growth stunted because we choose to water ourselves with the wrong things. If we would just accept that the Lord's way is best, our souls would not be wastelands nor society.
Luke Killam said…
This was a beautiful explication Becca! I love how you connected Silence to the Wasteland, because they do share many similar themes. I also love the point that "The sea was calm even when it looked wild." Great work!