The Nonsensical Way - Eliza Colbert

This book immediately made me think of a movie called La vita è bella (Life is Beautiful). It’s a heart-wrenching movie about an Italian-Jewish family who is taken to a concentration camp. I highly recommend it, although it is almost guaranteed to make you cry. I watched it in high school with my class and we were all crying by the end of it. 
Movie recommendations aside, this book is both hard and easy to read. It’s hard to read because of the subject matter; it’s a tough subject. And yet Levi makes it easy to read with the style he writes in. From the first page, he sets the tone of both caring and not-caring. What I mean is that he cares about the little details, adding the fact that refugees came searching for “a hiding place, a fire, a pair of shoes” (3). He cares enough to include small details like this, but he does it in such a nonchalant fashion. He doesn’t seem to care that much about what is happening. It seems like he has accepted it and that’s that, this is the way the world works now. 
Something else I noticed is the fact that he often refers to what is happening as nonsensical, incomprehensible, mad, crazy, strange, etc. In this way he is showing that, even though he has accepted this as the way his world is now, he still knows that it’s not right. People should not be treating other people this way. And that’s another point of the book: the prisoners aren’t human anymore. The Germans have taken their humanity from them. Now they are animals at best, lifeless pieces of a machine at worst. This is why we have the subtitle of the book: Survival in Auschwitz: If This is a Man. I’m interested to see how this theme continues to play out.


P.S. I commented on Osten’s and Caroline’s posts.

Comments

Rachael Gregson said…
Yes, I agree with you in this sense. I love how that while Liam and the other prisoners grew indifferent to those around them, they did not lose sight of what was wrong and what was right in the process. In situations like this, it's not uncommon for the line between those two things to be blurred, and I respect anyone who can maintain an eye for that because I'm personally not sure if I could.
Breanna Poole said…
I like what you said about the tone. The tone to me is such a strange thing to experience, because Levi is both apathetic and invested deeply. His tone almost reminds me of a textbook in some places, like he is simply stating this is how something is. Other times he injects so much humanity and passion into it that you feel very powerful emotions. I love your post!
Joshua Evers said…
I really appreciate the detail he gives. It brings the detail of a first person perspective yet at times I feel like he is not present when he retells aspects. There is a disconnect and perhaps the inhumane treatment only blurred the lines between his feelings and senses. I almost think he doesn't care about what happened and then question if he is trying to summon every ounce of sympathy I can produce. Good Post!