Gone with the Spirits // Moriah Nelson

What a book. Beyond the interesting form of writing used (which took a while to follow at first), the characters in Isabel Allende’s The House of the Spiritsmade me think of Margaret Mitchell’s Gone with the Wind. Esteban Trueba especially made me think of Scarlett O’Hara as they both were chasing after specific dreams and expected those around them to agree with their decisions and support them (and to both of their dismay, most did not support or understand their dreams and they both became frustrated and distraught as a result). I think it’s really interesting to look at Esteban’s desire for control-even in light of current events and our own loss of “control”. He wanted control over his destiny, his marriage, his home, and his children. At this point in the novel, it looks like he’s lost most, if not all, control in each of these areas and Esteban seems to be losing hope of leaving a reputable legacy (except possibly in politics). Esteban would have been far better off had he lived with more humility and recognized his own weaknesses and the consequences which followed his decisions. So far, from reading about Esteban’s life, I’ve been reminded of a lesson I learned from Scarlett O’Hara in high school: selfishness and pride do not benefit others nor ourselves, ultimately, and to live with the goal of loving our God and our neighbor is far better way to live our lives.
As the novel unfolds, I expect to see more change in Esteban's household but I'm not sure if he is willing to change his ways even if the world around him is rapidly changing...

I commented on Hailey and Drew's posts.

Comments

Drew Hedden said…
I hadn't necessarily viewed Esteban's issues as negatively affected by his desire for control but now that you say that it makes a lot of sense..It's honestly a huge warning against control and pride (at least for me) and I'm definitely glad you pointed that out. I do feel like a key part of character development for most people in the book is intention- what are they trying to do? I especially feel like mixed or unclear intentions for Ferula ended up ruining her life. I wouldn't be surprised if poor intentions end up completely ruining or even causing the death of Esteban.
Osten said…
Estaban's character is quite interesting. when first reading about him falling in love with rosa and pulling himself out of poverty so he could marry her would have been an amazing plot all on its own. I was rooting for him until he went for Clara who was obviously never interested in him to start with. I hated what he did to the villagers. It seems that his determined spirit to get what he wants gets him into more trouble than good just like Okonkwo. Makes you wonder what characteristic you are blind to that will get you into more trouble than good.
Clabo said…
I really liked how you pointed out Esteban's desire for control. Honestly his situation would not have ended so poorly if he could have at least controlled his temper along with all the other things you mentioned. I think his breaking point, however, was either when he kicked out his sister, or when he knocked out some of Clara's teeth. I really don't like this guy.